Instead of doing a full review of the trade, I’m going to focus on one team, the Mariners. This trade seemed like a win for each team. the Blue Jays got a good group of prospects, though I thought they would get a better package for Halladay. The Phillies swapped an ace for a little bit better ace that they could extend and some prospects to replenish the ones they lost to Toronto, but this trade only makes them slightly better in 2010.
The interesting team in this is the Mariners. They improved by 24 games in ‘09 and had a ton of money coming off the books this offseason. The addition of Chone Figgins, trade for Lee and the Angels losing important players has led to many predicting a great year for the Mariners in 2010. But will they really?
The addition of Cliff Lee paired with King Felix Hernandez gives them the best 1-2 punch in the AL, maybe the whole league. Signing Chone Figgins is a great addition for the offense and with Ichiro, that’s a tandem of terror both at the plate and on the bases for opposing teams. Second baseman Jose Lopez is a very good offensive player and Franklin Gutierrez is a nice centerfielder, but after that I don’t see anything elite about this team.
Obviously, the M’s still have money to spend and will probably acquire one more slugger. In my opinion that may not be enough. First base and Left Field need to be filled with a big slugger and another good offensive players. I think they should look hard into Bay/Holliday and Nick Johnson for their respective positions. Griffey is a glorified sentimental pick for DH, he should only be on the bench after a bad 2009 season. With a lot of better DH only options out there, they could have upgraded here. Jack Wilson is an alright SS and the catcher position is a non-factor. Two big offensive players are needed just to make this offense on par with the rest of the top AL teams.
After Hernandez-Lee, the starters is very weak. They need Ian Snell and Ryan Rowland-Smith to be much better in 2010, because at this point, they are a bunch of 5th starters. The M’s could use 1 more middle of the rotation starter. Maybe they can re-sign Jarrod Washburn, he seemed to be at his best in Seattle and will be a cheap option because of his terrible second half in Detroit.
If the Angels don’t do more to fill their gaping holes, the M’s can definitely sneak in to win the west with this current team. But, unless the M’s want to just be a team that will be eliminated in the ALDS there are a few more steps they must take.
