
The addition of Nick Swisher should greatly improve the Yankee's defense.
There has been a lot of talk around baseball that even with all the pitching the Yankee’s weakness will be their defense. ESPN’s Keith Law says it could be one of baseball’s worst. I don’t believe this to be true. Centerfield and first base are only getting stronger. I believe defense will be much approved this season over last. I will breakdown each position’s defense.
1. Catcher
Jorge Posada/ Jose Molina- Posada was one of the best defensive catchers in 2007, he threw out 30% of runners and started blocking the plate more, two things that weren’t his strong points in the past. In 2008, Posada never had a chance to get comfortable catching, his year was shortened by a shoulder injury. When he was catching, he couldn’t throw out any runner with his hurt shoulder. Posada is supposed to be healthy for the 2009 season. I’m not sure how healthy he really is, and he is another year older. If he can stay healthy he can be close to his 2007 form, but that is a big if. I don’t believe Posada will be any kind of liability.
Molina is more than an adequate defensive catcher. He throws out runners at a high rate, he threw out 33 of 42 runners in 2008, and rarely has passed balls. Molina is exactly what you want in a back up catcher. If Posada isn’t healthy enough to start as catcher all the time, Molina only improves the defense of the Yankees on a full-time basis.
Grade: B/A
2. First Base
Nick Swisher- Swisher, without a doubt is a huge defensive improvement over Jason Giambi. Swisher will add stellar defense to the Yankees. One of GM Brian Cashman’s justifications for adding Swisher was that the run production your losing from Giambi’s bat balances out with the runs you will save from being scored with Swisher’s glove. However, if Swisher can’t produce on offense or if Cashman wants to add a first baseman that has better offensive numbers than Swisher, that could weaken the Yankee’s defense.
Grade: A-
3. Second Base
Robinson Cano- Cano over recent years has improved defensively. However this is still the Yankee’s top weakness. Cano posts a .984% fielding percentage, which isn’t terrible. But, Cano seems slow to react to some ground balls, and lazy at times.
Grade: C
4. Shortstop
Derek Jeter- Jeter is another year older and questions remain to how long Jeter can stay at SS. Jeter makes a good amount of errors a season, but he makes up for it with the intensity he gives going after and making the tough plays. Also, his patent Jeter throw is still incredible, and Jeter can make that over the shoulder catch better than any other SS.
Grade: B+
5. Third Base
Alex Rodriguez- A-Rod is one of the best defensive third baseman in the game. He’s prone to boot a few balls a year, but no one can complain with his defense.
Grade: A-

Brett Gardner would be a perfect defensive fit for the Yankees.
6. Left Field
Johnny Damon- Damon isn’t a center fielder anymore. But, he plays a great left field in Yankee Stadium, and s overall good there. In 87 games in LF, Damon has only 1 error. Just can’t count on assists by Damon.
Grade: B+
7. Center Field
Brett Gardner/ Melky Cabrera/ Mike Cameron?- If the Cameron deal doesn’t go through, I see Gardner as the starting centerfielder. Gardner would be a perfect defensive upgrade for the Yankees. He’s fast and great defensively, no worries there. If Melky wins the job over Gardner in spring training, Melky wouldn’t be a bad everyday starting centerfielder. He has shown he can play good defense in center, and has a stellar arm. Cameron is a several time gold-glove winner, he’s an incredible defender in center. The only issue with Cameron is that he is in his late 30’s.
Grade: A+/A-/A
9. Right Field
Xavier Nady- Nady takes over RF from Abreu, a position he played daily in Pittsburgh. Nady plays good defense, and has a decent arm. Nothing to worry about. Nady doesn’t have the arm Abreu had, but isn’t afraid of that back wall like Abreu was.
Grade: B
Overall, I believe the Yankees will be fine on defense and I think the criticism about their defense is overblown. Cano is the big weakness, and if Posada’s catching skills have severely regressed because of the shoulder injury, that would be a great cause for concern.